Why is the subjunctive only used in one of these sentences?
I have the two sentences from a short story:
"El collar y los aretes que lleva hacen que Laura se vea muy hermosa." "¡Ellos también se ven bien!" I believe the subjunctive is used in the first since it is a value/opinion judgement and not objective reality. But I feel like that should apply to the second sentence as well. To be clear, the second sentence is saying that other people aside from Laura also look good. |
I'll give my thoughts on this because I was looking into this exact thing two days ago. I'm no expert, however, but it might be useful.
In your first example the subjunctive seems to be required simply as a marker of subordination, that is, it is grammatically required. "El verbo hacer + complemento + subjuntivo se traduce por to make + object + infinitive." E.g.: Hizo que me equivocara. He made me go wrong. The Romance Languages, Oxford University Press, 1988, has this general discussion on the Spanish subjunctive: "All varieties of Spanish preserve a vigorous subjunctive mood. Opinion is divided, however, on whether the subjunctive should be viewed as an independently meaningful category or as a 'mere' marker of subordination. Its use in many contexts is undoubtedly determined by grammatical factors ..." So, in other words, the construction using hacer requires the subjunctive as a grammatical rule. Your second example has no subordinate clause, and it appears to me to be indicative. |
I agree with elchocano. :)
I will add a few more examples: Here, it's important to learn that the verb "verse" is used to describe what something or someone looks like. - María se ve triste. Maria looks sad. - Mi casa se ve más bonita cuando la limpio. My house looks nicer when I clean it up. - Tu perro se ve contento. Your dog looks happy. - Estos calcetines se ven muy bien con zapatos deportivos. These socks look very well with sneakers. - ¿Cómo me veo? How do I look? - Te ves muy guapa con ese peinado. You look beautiful with that hairstyle. - Todas las concursantes se ven nerviosas. All the contestants look nervous. The next thing is that a construction with "hacer que", is followed by a verb in the subjunctive mood. (There is an exception, but we'll stay here for the moment.) ;) - ¿Crees que este vestido hace que me vea gorda? Do you think this dress makes me look fat? - El ruido hace que me duela la cabeza. The noise gives me a headache. - Los dulces hacen que los dientes se piquen. Sweets cause teeth to rot. - La publicidad hace que los jóvenes beban más alcohol. Advertising makes young people drink more alcohol. |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:58 AM. |
Forum powered by
vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.