The tense of second verb
View Full Version : The tense of second verb
gbpit
April 05, 2011, 06:50 PM
How is the tense of a second verb in a sentance determined?
Ex. Siempre llamo cuando ----- (tener) dinero. Tendría??
or
Siempre llamaba cuando ----(tener) dinero. Tuvo o tenía ??
This seems very confusing to me.
poli
April 05, 2011, 08:38 PM
How is the tense of a second verb in a sentance determined?
Ex. Siempre llamo cuando ----- (tener) dinero. Tendría??
or
Siempre llamaba cuando ----(tener) dinero. Tuvo o tenía ??
This seems very confusing to me.
It really depends on the meaning you wish to convey.
If you wish to convey that he/she alway called when she had some
money to spare you would say Siempre llamaba cuando tuvo dinero
If you wish to convey back in the days that he had money to spare
he always used to call--you would say: Cuando tenía dinero siempre
llamaba.
wrholt
April 05, 2011, 09:02 PM
How is the tense of a second verb in a sentance determined?
Ex. Siempre llamo cuando ----- (tener) dinero. Tendría??
or
Siempre llamaba cuando ----(tener) dinero. Tuvo o tenía ??
This seems very confusing to me.
In the pattern "Siempre X cuando Y", X and Y happen at the same time. In your first example, "tendría" isn't compatible with the time implied by "llamo".
In the second example, the time of your two suggestions is compatible with the time of the first part. The question to ask is which of those two suggestions is more compatible with the meaning of "siempre" = "always" (suggesting habit or usual behavior).
JPablo
April 05, 2011, 09:22 PM
I'd go with,
Siempre llamo cuando tengo dinero.
Siempre llamaba cuando tenía dinero.
I always call when I have money.
I always [used to] call when I had money.
Using the "imperfecto" "llamaba" "tenía" seems to go together with a "durative" sense, it can be used sometimes with the English progressive, as in "I was always calling when I had money" (for the second sentence.) :)
Luna Azul
April 07, 2011, 08:32 PM
How is the tense of a second verb in a sentance determined?
Ex. Siempre llamo cuando tengo (tener) dinero. Tendría?? :warning:Both verbs is in present indicative
or
Siempre llamaba cuando tenía (tener) dinero. Tuvo o tenía ?? :warning:Both verbs is past imperfect
This seems very confusing to me.
There are no other ways to say those verbs. ;)
vBulletin®, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.