PDA

Correct sentence in Spanish

View Full Version : Correct sentence in Spanish


Joystar1977
November 15, 2013, 05:11 PM
Juan es rapido. Corre rapidamente.

What is missing from this sentence? My teacher says it's only partially correct.

"estoy escuchando"

"estan dando"

" estas haciendo"

"estamos durmiendo"

"estoy viendo"

"estan leyendo"

What can I add to these phrases to make them correct? My teacher says they are only partially correct.

wrholt
November 15, 2013, 06:20 PM
Juan es rapido. Corre rapidamente.

What is missing from this sentence? My teacher says it's only partially correct.


The only obvious thing I notice is the lack of accent marks over vowels that need them. You could also mention the destination, the route, or both the destination and the route.


"estoy escuchando"

"estan dando"

" estas haciendo"

"estamos durmiendo"

"estoy viendo"

"estan leyendo"

What can I add to these phrases to make them correct? My teacher says they are only partially correct.

You are missing accent marks on many of the forms for "estar".

Five of these verbs are transitive verbs: phrases or sentences that contain these verbs normally need an explicit direct object to sound right.

One of these verbs can be used either with a direct object or without a direct object, but there are at least 3 different meanings for that verb: one meaning when the verb has no direct object, a different meaning when the verb has a non-reflexive direct object (direct object is not the subject of the verb), and a third meaning when the verb has a reflexive direct object (the direct object is also the subject of the verb).

With these hints can you think of any changes you might make to improve all of these examples?

By the way, the formatting toobar above the edit box for typing forum posts has a drop-down list named "Accents" that you can use to type all of the special characters for Spanish.

Joystar1977
November 16, 2013, 11:24 AM
Juan es rápido. Corre mas rápidamente.

Is this the correct way to say this sentence?

estoy escuchando = "lo qué estoy escuchando", "qué estoy escuchando", or "lo estoy escuchando"

están dando = "se están dando", "los están dando", or "las están dando"

estás haciendo = "lo qué estás haciendo", "qué estás haciendo", or "lo estás haciendo"

estamos durmiendo = "nos estamos durmiendo", "los estamos durmiendo", or "las estamos durmiendo"

estoy viendo = "yo estoy viendo" or "me estoy viendo"

están leyendo = "que los están leyendo", "qué están leyendo" or "los están leyendo"

Which one of these are correct? I don't understand when to use the personal pronouns either as a subject, an indirect object, or direct object. How am I supposed to know when to use the verb as the subject, direct object, or indirect object?

Liquinn3
November 16, 2013, 11:56 AM
Estoy escuchando is correct. However, I would wait to someone to confirm if the other ways to suggest are correct.

I do not have the correct answer to your grammar question, sorry. :(

Rusty
November 16, 2013, 12:06 PM
Juan es rápido. Corre mas rápidamente. (doesn't belong)

Is this the correct way to say this sentence?

estoy escuchando = "lo qué estoy escuchando", "qué estoy escuchando", or "lo estoy escuchando" (all three are correct, depending on what you want to say - the second one, beginning with the interrogative 'qué', needs to have proper punctuation - without the interrogative (without the accent mark, in other words), you have a sentence fragment))

están dando = "se están dando", "los están dando", or "las están dando" (all three are correct, depending on what you want to say)

estás haciendo = "lo qué estás haciendo", "qué estás haciendo", or "lo estás haciendo" (I marked one mistake - the second one that starts with the interrogative needs to have proper punctuation)

estamos durmiendo = "nos estamos durmiendo", "los estamos durmiendo", or "las estamos durmiendo" (dormir doesn't take a direct object)

estoy viendo = "yo estoy viendo" or "me estoy viendo" (both are correct but mean different things)

están leyendo = "que los están leyendo", "qué están leyendo" or "los están leyendo" (first one is a fragment, the second one starts with an interrogative, so must have proper punctuation - the third one is a good sentence)

I don't understand when to use the personal pronouns either as a subject, an indirect object, or direct object. How am I supposed to know when to use the verb (you meant pronoun) as the subject, direct object, or indirect object?You use Spanish pronouns nearly the same way you use English pronouns. You know what pronoun to use in English, if it's your mother tongue. You just have to learn why you use the particular one you do and choose the same pronoun in Spanish.

Joystar1977
November 16, 2013, 07:27 PM
Thanks Rusty for checking these sentences! I have a little bit of a problem with the previous sentences. I wasn't supposed to put the pronouns but the the present progressive form of the verbs in parentheses. I will let you know what they are as follows:

1. Juan (escuchar) la música.

2. Los artistas (dar) un concierto en el parque.

3. Tú (hacer) una gira por la ciudad.

4. Carlos y to (dormir).

5. Yo (ver) una película en el cine.

6. Ustedes (leer) el artícula sobre Shakira en Rolling Stone.

I at first put the following for the practice test:

1. Juan estoy eschuchando la música.

2. Los artistas están dando un concierto en el parque.

3. Tú estás haciendo una gira por la ciudad.

4. Carlos y yo estamos durmiendo.

5. Yo estoy viendo una película en el cine.

6. Ustedes están leyendo el artícula sobre Shakira en Rolling Stone.

The second time I took the practice test I put the following:

1. Juan lo qué estoy eschuchando.

2. Los artistas se están dando un concierto en el parque.

3. Tú lo qué estás haciendo una gira por la ciudad.

4. Carlos y yo nos estamos durmiendo.

5. Yo me estoy viendo una película en el cine.

6. Ustedes los qué están leyendo el artículo sobre Shakira en Rolling Stone.

My instructor marked these all wrong when I took the practice test for the second time. The instructions are to put the present progressive form of the verbs in parentheses. The feedback given was as follows: "Remember this form has two parts, first the form of the verb estar that goes with the subject "Juan", then add the appropriate -ing ending to escuchar. When I have looked in my Spanish verb book there isn't any verbs with the -ing ending for the verb escuchar. Can someone please explain to me what I am supposed to do here?

Rusty
November 16, 2013, 07:34 PM
You asked more or less the same question in another thread.
I answered you there and will add a link (http://www.spanish411.net/spanish-present-imperfect-progressive.asp) that may help you to understand how the present progressive is formed (it goes beyond the present tense, too).

The second round of sentences are incorrect. They mostly include information that wasn't in the original Spanish sentences.
Just change the infinitive in parentheses to the present progressive. You'll be adding two words only - the conjugated form of 'estar' (which must be in the present tense and must agree with the subject), plus the gerundio (English: present participle) of the infinitive in parentheses.