Still lost on estar and some ser stuff
View Full Version : Still lost on estar and some ser stuff
AlwaysLost
March 07, 2016, 11:32 PM
So I can ask basic questions about where things are, but my understanding stops there. So I believe "¿Donde está el cuaderno?" is correct, but then I wonder what the meaning of the variants are.
¿Donde estoy el cuaderno? = Where is my notebook? (this one I think is wrong). Think that
"mia" should be somewhere in there.
¿Donde estás el cuaderno? = Where is your notebook?
¿Donde está el cuaderno? = Where is the notebook?
¿Donde estámos el cuaderno? = Where is our notebook?
¿Donde están el cuaderno? = Where is their notebook?
Are these correct?
Also can I say "Soy no Comprendo" = I don't understand. <--- Is this correct?
Rusty
March 08, 2016, 12:46 AM
The variants you tried won't work.
The verb needs to agree in person and number with the subject.
Since 'el cuaderno' is referenced (not addressed, not self), it is a third person. Since there is only one notebook, the subject is singular third person.
The verb ending for singular third person is 'á', for the verb estar.
Use the possessive adjective 'mi' in front of 'cuaderno' to say 'my notebook'.
¿Dónde está mi cuaderno? = Where is my notebook?
The possessive adjectives, arranged according to person and number, are:
{|}mi, mis | nuestro/a, nuestros/as
{|}tu, tus | vuestro/a, vuestros/as
{|}su, sus | su, sus
¿Dónde está tu cuaderno? = Where is your notebook?
¿Dónde está nuestro cuaderno? = Where is our notebook?
¿Dónde están nuestros cuadernos? = Where are our notebooks?
The last sentence shows how a plural third-person subject changes the verb ending, from 'á' to 'án', and the possessive adjective ending, from 'o' to 'os'.
No entiendo = I don't understand
(No comprendo = I don't comprehend)
The verb ending, '-o', conveys the subject's person and number, so there's no need to use the subject pronoun 'yo' in front of 'no'.
Soy = I am
Soy no entiendo. = I am I don't understand. (This doesn't make sense.)
AlwaysLost
March 08, 2016, 02:23 PM
{|}mi, mis | nuestro/a, nuestros/as
{|}tu, tus | vuestro/a, vuestros/as
{|}su, sus | su, sus
We are no learning these in my class.
We have this:
Yo soy
Tu eres
él/ellos/usted es
Nosotros somos
Ellos son
Can you say ¿Dónde está somos cuaderno? = Where is our notebook?
AngelicaDeAlquezar
March 08, 2016, 03:36 PM
No, you can't. That's like saying "were is are we notebook". The problem is you're mixing up two different things: the verbs "ser" and "estar" and the use of possessive pronouns.
The verb "estar" talks about the situation of a thing or a person: where, how, when something/someone is.
The notebook is the subject of the sentence, so the verb only admits one conjugation: present indicative for él.
yo estoy
tú estás
él/ella está
nosotros estamos
vosotros estáis
ustedes están
ellos/ellas están
The verb "ser" talks about the inherent qualities of a thing or a person: what someone or something is.
yo soy
tú eres
él/ella es
nosotros somos
vosotros sois
ellos/ellas son
In order to answer where the notebook is, you only need one verb (not both), but if you want to include whose notebook it is, you need to know the possessive pronouns, and those are the ones Rusty presented.
They agree in gender and number according to the property's number and gender.
yo -> mi casa, mi hermano, mis maestras, mis lápices
tú -> tu goma, tu coche, tus amigas, tus cuadernos
él/ella -> su mamá, su reloj, sus lecciones, sus dibujos
nosotros -> nuestra escuela, nuestro salón, nuestras mochilas, nuestros compañeros
vosotros -> vuestra tarea, vuestro escritorio, vuestras clases, vuestros juegos
ustedes -> su computadora, su profesor, sus preguntas, sus teléfonos
ellos/ellas -> su oficina, su jardín, sus hijas, sus hijos
AlwaysLost
March 09, 2016, 02:43 PM
So could I say something along the lines of....
Me: ¿Donde está mi libro?
Me: Necesito leer.
Where is my book? I need to read.
I'm a little confused on the leer. I have read "leo", but also that when you have ser you only change the first describing word and not the ones after.
wrholt
March 09, 2016, 03:15 PM
So could I say something along the lines of....
Me: ¿Donde está mi libro?
Me: Necesito leer.
Where is my book? I need to read.
Perfect!
I'm a little confused on the leer. I have read "leo", but also that when you have ser you only change the first describing word and not the ones after.
"Leer" is the infinitive = "(to) read".
In the sentence "necesito leer", the first verb "necesito" requires a complement; that is, something that specifies what I need. One possible complement is the infinitive of a different verb, just like English "I need to X". You use an infinitive in the complement of "necesitar" when both verbs have the same subject.
AlwaysLost
March 09, 2016, 05:13 PM
Thank you for your help thus far. I'd give more rep, but the button is telling me that I have already given.
So if ser is used to describe qualities, does this work?
Soy guapo y inteligente = I am good looking and intelligent
Eres joven y tonto = You are young and stupid
Es guapa y simpática = She is good looking and likable
aleCcowaN
March 09, 2016, 05:33 PM
Soy guapo e inteligente = I am good looking and intelligent
Eres joven y tonto = You are young and stupid
Es guapa y simpática = She is good looking and likable
:thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:
y is replaced by e before i, no exception
it's the equivalent to "a car" but "an idea"
vBulletin®, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.