PDA

Why "Él está en la escuela" and not just "Él está en escuela"?

View Full Version : Why "Él está en la escuela" and not just "Él está en escuela"?


Spanish Objective
September 05, 2016, 05:44 PM
Why is it proper to say, "He is at school" as "El está en la escuela" in Spanish, instead of just "El está en escuela"?

Especially since "El está en casa" is like English in that it is just "He is at home".

Rusty
September 05, 2016, 06:00 PM
Note that 'en casa' means 'at home', even though 'casa' is the word for house, not home. This is a set phrase.
'In the house' is said 'en la casa'.

'En escuela' isn't a set phrase. You must say 'en la escuela'.

Spanish Objective
September 06, 2016, 01:23 PM
Note that 'en casa' means 'at home', even though 'casa' is the word for house, not home. This is a set phrase.
'In the house' is said 'en la casa'.

'En escuela' isn't a set phrase. You must say 'en la escuela'.

So would I always use "la/el/las/los" after prepositional phrases unless it is a set phrase?

Is there any way to know when to use set phrases always, or is it just by memory?

Rusty
September 06, 2016, 03:10 PM
Set phrases need to be memorized.

'En casa' isn't actually a prepositional phrase, by the way. It's an adverb of location (adverbio de lugar).

Yes, an article appears after the preposition and prior to the object. The preposition, the article and the prepositional object make up the prepositional phrase.

Spanish Objective
September 06, 2016, 05:12 PM
Set phrases need to be memorized.

'En casa' isn't actually a prepositional phrase, by the way. It's an adverb of location (adverbio de lugar).

Yes, an article appears after the preposition and prior to the object. The preposition, the article and the prepositional object make up the prepositional phrase.

Thank-you very much!