Spanish language learning forums

Spanish language learning forums (https://forums.tomisimo.org/index.php)
-   Grammar (https://forums.tomisimo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Word order (https://forums.tomisimo.org/showthread.php?t=19931)

Word order


Stu June 25, 2015 07:12 AM

Word order
 
This is an extract from a film

A Sandoval no lo mató Gómez.

I understand it means that Gómez did not kill Sandoval.

I expect to see subject pronouns come after the verb but subject nouns to come before the verb making Sandoval the subject. Obviously this rule does not seem to work here.
How do we know who is the actor and who is receiving the action?

aleCcowaN June 25, 2015 08:00 AM

The preposition "a" sorts it all out.

Just suppress the preposition and a native speaker won't be able to parse the sentence: "Sandoval no lo mató Gómez" would be contrued as "... a Gómez". Only a pause and a telegraphic style can do without the preposition, as in "Sandoval. No lo mató Gómez" which sounds a bit artificial.

Julvenzor June 25, 2015 08:10 AM

Hi Stu,

The preposition "a" before "Sandoval" indicates he cannot be the subject, but the DO. This is the explanation:

Gómez no mató a Sandoval => (Changing the order) *A Sandoval no mató Gómez*.

However, when the DO is placed before the verb, it's mandatory a duplication of acusative pronouns: lo/la/los/las.


A Sandoval no lo (<==singular male) mató Gómez.

A pleasure.

Stu June 28, 2015 06:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by aleCcowaN (Post 155399)
The preposition "a" sorts it all out.

Just suppress the preposition and a native speaker won't be able to parse the sentence: "Sandoval no lo mató Gómez" would be contrued as "... a Gómez". Only a pause and a telegraphic style can do without the preposition, as in "Sandoval. No lo mató Gómez" which sounds a bit artificial.

Thank you - great help

Stu June 28, 2015 06:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Julvenzor (Post 155400)
Hi Stu,

The preposition "a" before "Sandoval" indicates he cannot be the subject, but the DO. This is the explanation:

Gómez no mató a Sandoval => (Changing the order) *A Sandoval no mató Gómez*.

However, when the DO is placed before the verb, it's mandatory a duplication of acusative pronouns: lo/la/los/las.


A Sandoval no lo (<==singular male) mató Gómez.

A pleasure.


Thank you - Great that is clear and clears up my confusion.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:18 PM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.