![]() |
verb form ir + gerundio
¡Hola!
I would appreciate it if you could clarify the following point for me: The verb form ir + gerundio expresses the idea of a continuous action with a nuance that the action is developing gradually / little by little as exemplified in 1. Ese camión va perdiendo aceite. That truck is leaking oil. 2. Voy conociendo Madrid. I am getting to know Madrid (little by little). On the other hand, I have the following examples (from dictionaries): 3. Voy caminando al colegio todos los dias. I walk to school every day. How is it different from Ando / camino al colegio todos los dias (presente habitual)? 4.¡Voy volando! I’m on my way! / I must dash! I'd say there is nothing gradual about my condition of being in a hurry. How is it different from ¡Estoy en camino! Llegaré pronto! I’m on my way! I’ll be there soon? Would you comment on the accepted usage for examples 3 and 4 vs examples 1 and 2? Thank you. |
It's a stylistic choice. In most cases it + gerundio roughly translates to continues to+infinitive.
FYI: it is also common to hear seguir + gerundio to a similar effect. Please note that I am a native English speaker with working knowledge of Spanish. A native speaker may have something to add. |
Basically all four examples don't match the verbal periphrasis ir + gerundio, which describes dynamically some gradual or onsetting process.
Some basic examples Voy mejorando con la rehabilitación , lento pero seguro (I'm progressively getting better with rehabilitation, at a slow but steady pace) Los pasajeros tomaban sus equipajes de mano mientras el tren iba entrando en la estación (As the train entered the terminal, the passengers began to grab their hand baggage.) Your examples Ese camión va perdiendo aceite no periphrasis here, the lorry is leaking oil as it moves Ese camión va/anda/marcha/camina/avanza perdiendo aceite. Voy conociendo Madrid it doesn't make much sense as a standalone phrase Estoy yendo de una entrevista a otra todos los días, y mientras tanto voy conociendo Madrid. Voy al colegio todos los días (I go...) Voy caminando al colegio todos los días (I walk...) no periphrasis here either. ¡Voy volando! (I'll be there in a breeze! or, I'll be there asap!, Estaré allí en menos que canta un gallo) no periphrasis. |
Thank you, poli.
|
Thank you, aleCcowan.
|
Gracias por la explicación. Entonces, en ejemplos como «voy caminando al colegio», entiendo que ir + gerundio no forma la perífrasis, sino que «caminando» describe cómo voy al colegio.
|
I think that in am, go and continue walking have the same verbal function. If one is periphrasis, then the others should be as well.
|
@Sophie: I'm not so sure about the "perífrasis", but there is a difference when you describe an ongoing action as it's happening (which has a certain feeling of accumulation or something going on gradually) and when you modify the verb with a "gerundio" to describe the movement.
- ¿Qué te parece si me vas contando la historia en el camino? -> An action that keeps on happening along the way. - Los niños fueron entregando sus exámenes, uno por uno. -> An action that happened until all the children handed in their tests. When you say "voy caminando al colegio todos los días", you are describing the way you go to school (by walking); "caminando" modifies the verb, but it doesn't have an idea of gradual action happening. If you say "voy caminando al colegio" as an answer to the question "what are you doing?" you are describing the action as it's happening. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:38 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.