Cuál or Qué?

[poli]

Originally Posted by Alfonso

Poli, you say: ¿cuál es su título...?

Estimados hispanoparlantes,
Necesito su asisténcia. Pensaba que cuál significaba which.
¿Cual de los dos títulos es correcto?,por ejemplo.
Ahora veo que cuál a veces significa what tambien.
Tiene que ser un ley. ¿Cuál/qué es la ley?
Hablo español todos los días.(en mi modo), y quiero pulir mi estilo de hablar. Cuál/qué son unas de las pequeñas palabras que son trampas para mi.
Gracias

--------
This post was originally a reply to this thread. -Tomisimo

[María José]

Originally Posted by poli

Estimados hispanoparlantes,
Necesito su asistencia. Pensaba que cuál significaba which.
¿Cuál de las dos traducciones es la correcta?,(por ejemplo.)
Ahora veo que cuál a veces significa what también.
Tiene que ser una regla. ¿Cuál es la regla?
Hablo español todos los días.(a mi modo), y quiero pulir mi estilo de hablar. Cuál/qué son unas de las pequeñas palabras que son trampas para mi.
Gracias

Yo te hago las correcciones, la explicación se la dejo a Alfonso que controla más.

[Tomisimo]

I'd love to hear Alfonso's explanation as well, but I'll give it a try.

There are a few rules that will help you know when to use the interrogative pronouns ¿qué? and ¿cuál?.

1. Generally, qué = what and cuál = which, but there are some caveats.
2. Always use qué if a noun comes right after it: (Whether or not you would use which or what in English). Qué is used as an adjective here.

¿Qué regla es la que debo aplicar aquí? - What rule should I apply here?
¿Qué cosa? - What?
¿Qué color te gusta más? - What color do you like better?

3. Use qué to ask for an explanation, description, definition etc, when not followed by a noun: (qué is a pronoun here)

¿Qué es esto? - What is that?
¿Qué significa esa mirada? - What does that look mean?

4. If you use 'what' and you can substitue 'which' or 'which one(s)', then use cuál. Of course, using which or which one might sound stilted in English, but you can say which is the topic for today?, but you could never say *which means that look? Note that you're asking for a specific thing (regla, tema) instead of asking for an explanation, description, or definition as in #3.

¿Cuál es la regla? - What is the rule?
¿Cuál es el tema de hoy? - What is today's topic?
¿Cuál de los dos me queda mejor? - Which one fits me better?
¿Cuáles son las notas de esta canción? - What are the notes for this song?

5. Note that cuál is never used with a noun right after it.

[poli]

Thank you very much, David. Your explanation or the rule is very clear
You are quite helpful.

Poli

[María José]

I wouldn't have been able to write such a wonderful explanation, David.

[Tomisimo]

Originally Posted by poli

Thank you very much, David. Your explanation or the rule is very clear
You are quite helpful.

Poli

Thank you. If Alfonso comes along and feels up to giving an explanation, I'd love to hear what he has to say too.

[Tomisimo]

Originally Posted by Gemma

I wouldn't have been able to write such a wonderful explanation, David.

It's funny, as far as explaining rules goes, I know Spanish grammar better than English grammar.

[Marsopa]

I think it was the best I have ever read!

However, it seems to me that I have heard cuál used before a noun in exclamations when expressing surprise.

¡Cuál regla!? (Like what rule are you talking about?!)

Or am I imagining this?

Marsopa

[María José]

You might be imagining it. I would never say that. Maybe in South America...

[María José]

Originally Posted by Tomisimo

It's funny, as far as explaining rules goes, I know Spanish grammar better than English grammar.

Same thing here, but the other way around.

[Tomisimo]

Originally Posted by Marsopa

However, it seems to me that I have heard cuál used before a noun in exclamations when expressing surprise.

¡Cuál regla!? (Like what rule are you talking about?!)

Or am I imagining this?

I'll let a native speaker answer that

[María José]

I just did. But maybe I don't count.... Nobodys me.

[Tomisimo]

Originally Posted by Gemma

I just did. But maybe I don't count.... Nobodys me.

Sorry about that, actually I hadn't seen your post when I wrote mine.

[poli]

One more question about cuál.
Could you say, "cual es la regla, dime cuál"?
Thanks.

[Tomisimo]

Yes, that sounds fine to my ears.

[María José]

I agree with David. Well-tuned ears, boss.

[Alfonso]

Originally Posted by Marsopa

... when expressing surprise: ¿Cuál regla?
Or am I imagining this?
Marsopa

I'm sorry I really edited your post, Marsopa. But I think it will be clearer for this. I think you did hear such an expression. But it's not correct. I don't think it's got something to do with surprise. It's only a incorrect habit some people have.

I'll try to add something to what David wrote (it will be difficult)... after dinner . See you then!

[Tomisimo]

Originally Posted by Alfonso

I'll try to add something to what David wrote (it will be difficult)... after dinner . See you then!

Provecho!

[Jane]

Originally Posted by Tomisimo

Provecho!

Can you also say aproveche!, que aproveche! or is it my ear?

[Rusty]

Originally Posted by Jane

Can you also say aproveche!, que aproveche! or is it my ear?

¡Provecho!
¡Buen provecho!
¡Qué aproveche!

And, I guess you can just say "¡Aproveche!"
but that seems more along the lines of 'take advantage of it' instead of 'enjoy your meal'. Let's see what others say.